Unflattering comparison

Re: "Potus again presses Congress on voter bill", (World, March 10).

Donald Trump invites comparison to authoritarian strongmen not because history repeats itself perfectly, but because the pattern is familiar.

Like authoritarians such as Hitler, he builds politics around grievance and personal loyalty, demanding devotion not to institutions or the law, but to himself.

Enemies -- immigrants, political opponents, journalists -- are cast as threats to the nation, while the leader alone claims the power to restore greatness. Truth becomes elastic, reality negotiable and power a spectacle performed for crowds.

Around such a figure, the cabinet ceases to resemble a council of independent officials and begins to look more like a court.

Marco Rubio plays the role of the polished emissary, the man who dresses raw nationalism in diplomatic language and calls confrontation "strength".

Joseph Goebbels, the architect of public narratives that masked coercion with polish, played a similar role under Hitler.

Pete Hegseth, a self-described religious zealot, supplies the militarised fervour, translating political anger into talk of discipline, internal enemies and national rebirth through force.

Mr Hegseth's view of himself as a holy crusader arguably makes him an even more effective and dangerous instrument of authoritarian consolidation than Werner von Blomberg, Hitler's Minister of War.

Taken together, this dynamic shows how a central figure can bend a cabinet around a single will. Each actor embodies a specific function -- propagandist, enforcer, diplomat and commander -- designed to sustain the illusion of legitimacy before the nation. The point of the comparison is not that the United States has become Nazi Germany. It hasn't.

The point is that disguised authoritarian systems rarely announce themselves all at once. They grow through habits: loyalty tests, contempt for democratic norms, the normalisation of cruelty toward outsiders -- even those within the nation's own borders -- and the steady elevation of one man above the law.

Ultimately, war is the logical conclusion of authoritarian consolidation. War gives total control to the incumbent leader as everything becomes a "national emergency".

This authoritarian sideshow has now progressed to the chapter of war. Emboldened by a gradual erosion of institutional checks and the ability to suppress public outcry, Mr Trump has ordered the military to wage an illegal war on Iran without consent from either Congress or the American people.

What he did not count on, however, was the tenacity of the Iranians.

M L Saksiri Kridakorn

Trump's aplomb

Re: "Middle East shock", (PostBag, March 13).

The staunchly anti-American ML Saksiri Kridakorn consistently voices poorly considered views, but his latest claims that Iranian efforts to destabilise the petrodollar by targeting anything their crumbling military can hit will cause the US stock market to crash, inflation to rise into double digits and the economy to tank are patently absurd.

Despite a concerted effort by mainstream media to distort the truth, the US is one of the world's major oil producers with enormous strategic oil reserves.

Higher global prices driven by supply disruptions allow American oil companies to increase profits and domestic production, shifting energy reliance away from the Middle East.

Furthermore, the US military is now focused on safeguarding the Straight of Hormuz. President Trump will weather this temporary but necessary exercise with his customary aplomb and move on to bigger fish to fry. The people of Iran will thank him. Even CNN and their ilk are profiting too, albeit for the wrong reasons.

Michael Setter

End what you started

Re: "Attack by Iran send oil soaring", (BP, March 13).

As the energy prices rise sharply, the support for the war against Iran eases. Even calling this a war is an uncertain descriptor.

America and its friend Israel are bombing the daylights out of Iran who is returning the attack on Israel and a number of countries that are friends of America or at least have a base there.

The definition of friend and foe now seem almost interchangeable as the US has allowed some Russian oil to flow so that energy prices won't escalate and Republicans can hope they won't get the blame and lose a number of midterm seats.

When you need to rely on your worst enemy then you need to reconsider your battle plan, Mr President.

Please do everything to stop at least this war that you started.

Dennis Fitzgerald
14 Mar 2026 14 Mar 2026
16 Mar 2026 16 Mar 2026

SUBMIT YOUR POSTBAG

All letter writers must provide a full name and address. All published correspondence is subject to editing and sharing at our discretion

SEND